SMART INVESTING NEWSLETTER
US Advantages, Snacking in the US, Stock Market, Premium Financed Life Insurance, Food Expiration Dates, Writer Strike, Mortgage Rates, UAW Strike, Job Market, Cereal Sales and Interest Rates
US Advantages
I always enjoy seeing advantages of the United States over China. In the recent book “Chip War” written by Chris Miller he writes that across the entire semiconductor supply chain, including chip design, intellectual property, tools, fabrication and other steps, the Chinese only has a 6% market share. That compares to 39% for the US, South Korea at 16% and Taiwan at 12%. The author also points out as China pushes forward with cloud computing, autonomous vehicles, and AI its market share will continue to grow. The x86 server chips will be the workhorse of modern data centers which are dominated by AMD and Intel.
Snacking in the US
I can’t remember the last time I had a Twinkie, but apparently, I’m in the minority. The snack business overall in the US is up 8% in the past two years with consumers eating three or more snacks a day. Overall, US snacks increased by 11% last year to a total of $181 billion. The demand has led to 1 million Twinkies being produced each day. This could be why J.M. Smucker recently paid $4.6 billion for Hostess brands which over the last 15 years has filed bankruptcy twice. Twinkies were started back in the 1920s by James Dewar who delivered pound cakes from a horse drawn carriage. If you want to know where the name Twinkie came from, Mr. Dewar came up with the idea after passing a billboard for Twinkie toes shoes. He thought Twinkies would be a great name for a snack. Hostess which owns Twinkies filed for bankruptcy back in 2004 and again in 2012 after the company failed due to a strike over a labor deal with the Baker’s union. It looks like this time being owned by J.M. Smucker; Twinkies will last longer. You may not know this, but they also prolonged the life of a Twinkie from 26 days to now they will last on the shelf for 65 days. I guess I will have to try a Twinkie and bring back the days of my school lunches when I was a kid.
Stock Market
You may be worried about investing because of the high levels of the stock market. At Wilsey Asset Management, we have talked about how it’s an overconcentrated market and overall, it is still expensive. Famed investor Warren Buffet also feels the market is expensive, he has what’s known as the Buffet indicator, which he uses to see when the market is expensive. He compares the Wilshire 5000 index to the GDP of the country. The perfect market price is when the market has the same value as the GDP. Buffet points out that the Wilshire 5000 is currently $49 trillion, well above the GDP at $26.9 trillion. To bring the Buffet indicator from a high level of 182% down to 100%, the market would need a decline of 45%. No one, including Buffet, expects to see a 45% decline in the market. What I have said, and agree with Warren Buffett on is that for the next 5 to 10 years we will not have much of a gain in the overall market as the GDP will increase to catch up to the index and normalize the ratio. To make money in your portfolio going forward one must remember it is not a stock market, but a market of stocks and one has to find good stocks that are of good value with good dividends. This will bring the investor better returns over the next 5 to 10 years.
Financial Planning: Premium Financed Life Insurance
Cash value life insurance is sometimes sold as a retirement planning vehicle. Premiums are paid with after-tax dollars which covers the fees, cost of insurance, and builds cash value. If enough cash value is accumulated, you can take out loans against it, which is not taxable because it is technically debt. In retirement, the cash value can continue to grow tax deferred while loans can be structured as a “tax-free” income source. The loan balance increases from the withdrawals and compounding interest, but the income/loans may continue as long as the loan balance does not exceed the cash value of the policy. At death, the life insurance death benefit is used to pay off the outstanding loan balance.
One challenge for these types of plans is they require substantial amounts of cash value collateral to produce a worthwhile income stream. To build the necessary cash value, extremely large premiums are required which can be difficult to add into someone’s budget. This is where premium-financed life insurance comes in. Instead of the policy owner paying the premiums themselves, they obtain a 3rd party loan to pay the high premiums and then make payments on that loan. The hope is that the cash value will grow faster than the loan balance and at some point in the future, a second loan can be taken against the insurance cash value to repay the loan used to pay the premiums. At that point, additional loans can be taken from the cash value to produce the “tax-free retirement income”. It may go without saying but this type of plan can get complicated and risky pretty quickly. If structured correctly and with some luck, this strategy can produce some retirement income, but there are so many areas where it can fail, and when you invest using debt and fail, the losses are compounded. High net worth and accredited investors can be attracted to these plans from believing they need a more sophisticated and tax-advantaged strategy, and advisors are happy to sell them because of the massive commissions that come along. However, these plans are extremely risky and in pretty much every case there is a more appropriate alternative.
Food Expiration Dates
My wife and I disagree on food expiration dates. When she sees the expiration date, that is when she wants to throw out the food. My response is if it still tastes OK there’s no problem. That came from my grandma many years ago. I’m happy to say the experts agree that expiration dates are useless and this has caused American households to throw away 80 billion pounds of food on an annual basis. What people don’t understand is a couple things. First, the dates originally came out as a coded system for manufacturers to communicate to retailers when to rotate their stock. It’s also so confusing with many different labels, such as fresh until, best when used by, or best before. There are many other reasons behind these dates and some manufacturers just put a date on with no explanation at all. Many consumers believe these dates on food comes from the government or the FDA and that is not true with the exception of baby formula. John Hopkins University and Harvard found that 84% of consumers throw out food based on a date on the package occasionally and 37% always threw out the food on the date on the package. It is recommended that your refrigerator be set no higher than37° to keep your food fresher. Experts also say while food may not taste as good as before it is not unhealthy.
Writer Strike
The writer strike started back in May, and was followed by the actors striking in July. It is starting to show some signs of strain. Two well-known entertainers in the industry, Bill Maher and Drew Barrymore have crossed the picket lines to get back to work. They realize that the strike has hurt so many other people who are trying to make a living producing their shows and they feel they can still do their shows without the writers. We could see more well-known names follow suit and put pressure on both the actors and the writers to come back to the table to negotiate a deal before the entire strike falls apart.
Mortgage Rates
Part of the reason for the higher mortgage rates is that investors are demanding higher yields to compensate for the uncertainty in the economy. Also, demand for mortgages has fallen off dramatically, especially with the Fed who used to purchase massive amounts of mortgage bonds virtually shutting down buying any mortgage-backed securities. What this has led to is nearly a 3% spread for the 10-year treasury and the 30-year mortgage which is well above the average over the last 50 years of about 1.75%. The last time we experienced such a large spread was during the financial crisis in 2008. I would like to say we will see this change soon, but I hate to say I don’t see any changes in this scenario until perhaps mid-2024, maybe later.
UAW Strike
The strike by the UAW against the big automakers could have a ripple effect across the economy. While we still have a strong job market, it is slowing down somewhat, and depending on how the strike ends it could put more pressure on the economy and inflation. The problem is with a tight labor market, labor does have more leverage, but if the settlement with the UAW looks too good for the workers that may encourage other unions to bargain harder for better wages as well. My recommendation to the auto companies is give the workers something fair, but hold strong because if they don’t the automobile makers could have financial issues 3 to 5 years down the road by being too easy on negotiating a deal that could also hurt other companies as well. Some short-term pain now could make life for everyone easier down the road.
Job Market
The job market is showing some signs of slowing down, but there is still nothing to worry about at this time. In August, the percentage of American workers who feared getting laid off rose to 13.8%, which was the highest since April 2021. This can also be considered perhaps good news as the Federal Reserve has been watching the job market closely and is looking for a slowdown to ease wage inflation.
Cereal Sales
If you’re thinking of investing in old companies like General Mills, Kellogg and Post Holdings just because they’ve been around for many years, you may want to think again. These three companies are well known for their cereal products which were popular back in the 80s and 90s, but now people are looking more for protein and a quick breakfast like breakfast sandwiches or burritos on the way to work. In 2020 during the pandemic, cereal sales increased 5.2%. This compares to the 3% decline in 2019. After the gain in 2020, they had a large decline in 2021 falling 8.7% and then fell another 3.9% in 2022. Next month Kellogg will spin off the cereal division into a new company named after the founder who invented cereal about 100 years ago with the name WK Kellogg. While this may sound kind of fun investing in history, I will remind investors it’s not a good idea to invest in any company that has a product with declining sales. It is possible that maybe they can reverse the decline. I don’t know about you, but I cannot remember the last time I had a bowl of cereal even though I still can remember commercials for Tony the Tiger, Captain Crunch and Cheerios.
Interest Rates
Even though there was no rate hike from the Fed, there are still some concerns around where the Fed is projecting rates will be. While I do believe rates will remain higher over the coming years, I don’t give much weight towards the Fed’s projections considering how wrong they were on inflation in 2021/2022 and how quickly they pivoted. At the end of 2021, the Fed forecasted it would raise rates three times and end 2022 below 1%. This compares to the seven hikes in 2022 and a target rate of 4.25%-4.50% at the end of the year.