SMART INVESTING NEWSLETTER
Smart Investing Weekly Recap 1/13-1/17/2020
1. Have you ever noticed that many companies incorporate in Delaware? According to a recent study more than half of the fortune 500 companies chose to incorporate in Delaware. On top of a business friendly tax structure, Delaware offers other less thought about benefits to corporations. The state offers good privacy for the business as director and officer names are not required in the formation documents. The state also allows good flexibility for companies when structuring the business and its board. As an example, Delaware allows just one person to be the only director, shareholder and officer of a corporation. In other states, you may need a minimum of three people to hold the officer and director positions. The court system is also a major advantage as the Delaware Court of Chancery uses judges rather than juries. This allows litigation to be resolved by a judge without expertise in complex corporate matters rather than a jury that likely lacks corporate knowledge.
2. I want to see Boeing turnaround as it is an American manufacturer that creates American jobs, but I cannot justify an investment in this business. As more time passes, it seems only more bad news gets added to the equation. In 2019, Boeing lost orders for 87 commercial planes. It was the first time in at least the last 30 years that Boeing had a loss in orders and it compares to competitor Airbus seeing orders of 768 new planes. As the Max remained grounded, Boeing had delive ries of just 380 commercial planes for the year. This was the lowest since 2007 and compares to Airbus deliveries of 768 planes. Moody’s has also indicated it is putting the company’s debt on a 90-day review for a possible downgrade. This could lead to more expensive debt financing for a business that is already having cash flow problems. With all of these problems the stock still trades at an expensive 20.6x expected 2020 EPS. At these levels, the stock is not worth the risk.
3. I have discussed index investing in the past and while it has been a strong strategy over the last 10 years to invest in the S&P 500, I worry about the next 10 years. While the valuations are now above historic levels, I worry even more about the concentration of the index. People invest in the S&P 500 because they feel the index is diversified, but as large cap stocks have gained in price they now occupy large portions of the index. Apple, Microsoft, Alphabet, Amazon and Facebook now make up about 18% of the total S&P 500. That’s a large percentage for just 5 tech driven businesses, what about the other 495 components?
4. People often times complain about the rising cost of college, but much of it is driven by demand and poor cost control. In a recent study looking at full-time faculty in the University of California system from 1975 – 2008, the level of those employed rose from 11,614 to 12,019. This is clearly not the problem, but the number of university admin on the other hand has grown at a crazy rate. During the same time frame, university administrators grew from about 3,000 to 12,183. This includes new positions such as diversity officers. What is the ROI of all these new positions that have been created? It’s no wonder college costs have soared over the last few decades.
5. As a follow up to yesterday’s post on Boeing, I wanted to address the topic of too big to fail. While I believe if Boeing’s problems continued and they continued to bleed cash, the government would likely step in, it doesn’t mean the shareholders are safe. Looking at the most recent major bankruptcy of GM provides a good case study. As cash was being burnt and debt was mounting, GM was forced to file bankruptcy in 2009. Shareholders of pre-bankruptcy GM saw their shares fall to just $0.75 and had their investments essentially wiped out. Not even bondholders were safe as investors with $27 billion worth of GM bonds received stock in the new company, but it was worth a fraction of their initial investment. It is important to understand there is a difference between pre-bankruptcy GM and post-bankruptcy GM. Shareholders that hold shares of a bankrupt company can lose their entire investment and then that company can reorganize and issue new shares to new shareholders, as was the case with GM. It is interesting looking at the numbers as the government spent close to $50 billion in bailing out GM, but it did receive a stake of 61% in new GM and in all it only cost tax payers $11.2 billion. While I’m not saying Boeing will file bankruptcy, I am concerned if the problems are not resolved as planes sit idle and costs mount with unhappy customers wanting pay for lost travel time. Pair this with nearly $25 billion worth of debt on the balance sheet and I stand by my point that BA is not worth the risk at this time.
6. As we closed out 2019, the consumer remained strong and holiday retail sales had a phenomenal year. Excluding automobile dealers, gas stations, and restaurants retail sales grew 4.1% to $730.2 billion from November – December. This was at the high end of the National Retail Federation’s estimate of growth between 3.8% and 4.2%. It also compares favorably to the 2018 holiday season which saw growth of just 2.1%. The 2018 season suffered from interest rate hikes and stock market declines which dented consumer feelings. As more people are working, wages are rising, and assets remain at strong levels I believe 2020 will produce another year of a strong consumer.
7. Yesterday President Trump and China signed the phase one trade deal. While this has been known about for several weeks now, we finally got more clarity on what was involved. China has agreed to purchase an additional $200 billion of U.S. goods over the next 2 years. The additional amount will be tacked onto the 2017 export levels. This would bring China export levels to $263 billion in 2020 and $309 billion in 2021 and would be a record breaking acceleration in U.S. exports to China. For the particular industries China has promised to import an additional $77.7 billion in manufactured goods, $32 billion in agricultural goods, $52.4 billion in energy goods, and $37.9 billion in services over the next 2 years. A particular breakdown of goods within the industry’s has not been provided, but some of the promised purchases include soybeans, swine meat, liquified natural gas, petroleum oil, iron & steel products, antibiotics, financial services, cloud computing services, and charges for use of IP. While some tariffs were reduced, others remain in place as negotiations continue. Overall this is a major benefit for stocks as some uncertainty has been removed.
8. Exactly 100 years ago today, prohibition began with the ratification of the 18th Amendment and the passage of the Volstead Act. The experiment had an adverse impact as nearly a quarter of a million people lost their jobs and the restaurant industry struggled to survive. It’s also estimated that the federal government lost close to $11 billion in tax revenue and spent more than $300 million regulating prohibition. This also led to the creation of the bootleg market which saw earnings of $3.6 billion in 1926 or approximately $50 billion in current dollars. More than 13 years later, on December 5th, 1933, the 21st Amendment repealed the 18th Amendment and now the industry is worth over $100 billion in annual revenues. Maybe the Government doesn’t always know what is best for the consumer? Enjoy your weekend and don’t drink and drive.
9. Positive economic reports out today as US housing starts and the JOLTS report look promising. The housing starts really blew the numbers out of the water as an annual rate of 1.608 million easily topped estimates of 1.375 million and was the highest level since December 2006. Compared to November, housing starts were up 16.9% for the fastest growth rate since October 2016 and compared to last December starts grew at a staggering rate of 40.8%. With such high demand, I still see homebuilders as a sound investment unless we have interest rise at an uncontrollable rate. Looking at the JOLTS report, job openings did fall by 561,000 to 6.8 million but this comes as the unemployment rate has fallen over the years and the total number of people employed is at an all-time record. The reason I still see this report as positive is because openings still exceed those considered unemployed by close to 1 million.
This newsletter is for informational purposes only and should not be used as investment advice. If you would like to discuss more in detail your investment needs or have other investment questions, feel free to call me at 858-546-4306 or visit our website at Smartinvesting2000.com.