SMART INVESTING NEWSLETTER
PPI, CPI, Private Credit, Netflix & NFL Streaming, Best Withdrawal Rate for Retirement, Tariffs on China, Meme Stocks, April Retail Sales, Equity Settlement Times and Online vs. Brick-and-Mortar
PPI
Initially the Producer Price Index (PPI) looked problematic as it increased 0.5%, which easily topped the estimate of 0.3%. Looking further into the report though, the March reading was revised from an initially reported 0.2% gain to a decline of 0.1%, which more than accounted for this month’s beat. Looking on a year-over-year basis, PPI rose 2.2% and core PPI was 2.4%. While the core PPI increase was the biggest annual move since August 2023, I still don’t believe it’s at a problematic level considering the Fed’s 2% target.
CPI
The Consumer Price Index (CPI) brought some positive news as the index grew 3.4% in April which was in line with expectations and better than the previous month’s reading of 3.5%. Core CPI which excludes food and energy was up 3.6% and was below last month’s reading of 3.8%. This was the lowest reading for core CPI since April 2021. Shelter continues to be the major weight keeping prices elevated as it was up 5.5% over last year and accounted for over two thirds of the growth in core CPI. Energy which was a major positive for the CPI numbers for much of last year has now brought some pressure to the headline CPI number as it was up 2.6% compared to last year. The easy comparisons from last year have disappeared and now I believe we will continue to see year over year gains in the energy component moving forward. Other areas that remained problematic included motor vehicle insurance (+22.6%), admission to sporting events (+15.4%), and motor vehicle repair (+9.8%). While there are some remaining negatives in the inflation fight, overall, I believe this report shows we are continuing to head in the right direction.
Private Credit
I have seen investors become more interested in the private credit space, but personally I have not invested any money in it, nor would I recommend my clients do so. Private credit is where nonbank financial institutions, like private-equity firms, make loans to businesses. It was essentially created to serve companies that were too big or risky for banks or too small for the bond market. The funds are generally illiquid, which means you could be stuck in an investment and if it goes south, you may have no other choice than to ride it out and hope it comes back. Also, since they rarely trade you don’t really know what the loans are worth and have to rely on pricing from quarterly accounting estimates. The fees are quite high as they are in the range of 1.25%, which I would consider high for essentially a fixed income alternative. Unknown risks could also be developing in the space due to less regulations and limited oversight. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) recently released a report that stated with the recent increase in yields, more than a third of borrowers have interest costs that exceed their earnings. Pull all the info together and I’m comfortable not being in this investment.
Netflix and NFL Streaming
Netflix secured a deal for three years to broadcast two Christmas NFL games this year and at least one game in both 2025 and 2026. It’s going to cost Netflix $150 million this year and I’m wondering how they will make money off this deal. I wonder if they will be able to sell as many commercials as the big networks that currently own many of these rights and what viewership will look like on the platform. It’s also important to point out that the games this year will also air on broadcast TV in the competing teams’ cities. To breakeven, Netflix would need to attract a lot of new subscriptions and using strictly the subscription model of $23 per month, Netflix would have to increase their subscriptions by 6,521,739 just to breakeven. Obviously, it will be a combination of ad revenue and subscriptions, but I believe this will be a money loser for Netflix.
Financial Planning: Best Withdrawal Rate for Retirement
The 4% rule has been around for decades and states if retirees withdraw 4% from their portfolio every year, and increase the annual withdrawals by the rate of inflation, they are very unlikely to run out of money. This rule of thumb has been widely used but it is important to understand it has some pitfalls. First off, a 4% withdrawal rate is overly conservative in almost all cases. To be able to withdraw 4% plus inflation over a retirement lasting 30 years, the asset return needs to outpace inflation by just 1%. A 1% real return is extremely low. This is partly caused by the misconception that retirees need to have an overly conservative portfolio. Regardless of age, retirees still should allocate their assets to grow and outpace inflation. That doesn’t mean they need to buy risky or trendy investments, but there should always be growth. Retirees are living longer and longer which means traditional “conservative” portfolios are actually riskier because they increase the chance of outliving money. Secondly, retirement spending typically doesn’t maintain pace with inflation. In the first few years of retirement, people are more active and spending more, but as they age, they tend to slow down which results in lower levels of spending. This means it can be appropriate to start with a larger withdrawal rate followed by smaller inflationary increases over time. Because of this, a 5% or even 6% withdrawal rate can be used in retirement when paired with wise investment management. A withdrawal rate of 6% may not seem like much more than 4%, but mathematically it is 50% more which means substantially more retirement income, or being able to retire several years sooner.
Tariffs on China
This week President Biden not only extended President Trump‘s tariffs on China, but actually increased them. The Biden administration announced new tariff rates on $18 B worth of Chinese imports. This included a 4x increase on imported Chinese electric vehicles from 25% to 100%, a 2x increase on solar cells from 25% to 50%, and a more than 3x increase for some Chinese steel and aluminum imports from 7.5% to 25%. Also, starting in 2025 tariffs on imported Chinese semiconductors will go from 25% to 50%. This will help prevent US auto makers from perhaps filing bankruptcy in a few years as they would be unable to compete with the cheap prices on China’s electric vehicles. However, the US auto makers will have to sharpen their pencils to make profits and to compete on a global scale as China is producing and selling to the global market. I was glad to see Biden increase these tariffs and not let them expire just because former President Trump established them. You may ask yourself did President Biden do it for political election reasons with the election coming up in November? I would not rule that out, but I would say as bad as our system seems to be sometimes, maybe it is still working to benefit our country.
Meme Stocks
Meme stocks are back in the news with companies like GameStop (GME) and AMC Entertainment (AMC) surging! AMC was actually quite smart and took advantage of the move to do a $250 million stock sale to raise capital. Like I said back in 2021, these moves are occurring for no fundamental reason. The fact that these are occurring because a guy that goes by the name “Roaring Kitty” posted an image of a man in chair leaning forward is just crazy. If you want to gamble on this stock just know that’s all it is, there is no fundamental reason for the company’s stock to be trading at these levels. It’s also important to remember that last time the hype occurred the stock reached an intra-day split adjusted high of $120.75 per share and has been in free fall before this recent move as it touched a three year low of $9.95 per share. I believe the story will end the same way for many of these traders and for those that think they are sticking it to Wall Street, unfortunately it will not have as big of an impact as they think.
April Retail Sales
Although April Retail Sales were flat compared to March, when looking at last April they were up 3.0%. I believe this continues to indicate a consumer that is willing to spend, but at a slower rate. Areas of strength included nonstore retailers (+7.5%), food services & drinking places (+5.5%), and gas stations (+4.0%). While electronics & appliance stores saw a small gain of 0.8%, both furniture & home furnishing stores (-8.4%) and building material & garden equipment &supplies dealers (-1.0%) continued to struggle. Overall, I believe this report is a positive as it shows consumers remain in a good spot, but not too good of a spot that might put more pressure on inflation.
Equity Settlement Times
It’s always been a little bit inconvenient over the years to have the two-day settlement time when selling equities. It was frustrating at times when we would sell an equity on Thursday and our clients would not have good funds until after the weekend on Monday. It wasn’t until that time that we could send them a check. The head of the SEC, Gary Gensler, who has been a tough regulator will make it possible that when an equity is sold one day the cash will be available the next day. Don’t call your broker tomorrow and sell and expect funds the next day though as this will not be available until after Memorial Day weekend. I do remember when I first got into the industry 40 years ago, there was a five-day settlement period. Progress and technology have definitely helped the consumer with this situation.
Online vs. Brick-and-Mortar Shopping
Many years ago, people were certain that the internet and online orders would wipe out the brick-and-mortar stores. Something no one seemed to think about was the combination of the two. Currently 42% of e-commerce orders also have bricks and motor stores. This is a huge increase from 27% nine years ago. It makes sense to me because I think it’s still nice to sometimes go into the store. Also, it can be more convenient if you order online and are not happy with that purchase to go into the store to return or exchange it. At that time, you could even do more shopping if you wanted or needed.