SMART INVESTING NEWSLETTER
Jobs, Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE), National Retail Federation (NRF), SEC, Carvana, Gross Domestic Product (GDP), JOLTS, General Motors, US Debt, Inflation & Housing Market
Jobs
Job gains showed a nice increase of 263,000 in November which easily topped the estimate of 200,000. Leisure and hospitality remained a major leader with job gains totaling 88,000 in the month as the sector continues to battle back from Covid. This sector still remains 5.8% or 980,000 jobs below February 2020. Retail trade and transportation and warehousing were the standout losers in the report as both sectors saw a decline in payrolls. Retail trade fell by about 30,000 jobs as general merchandise stores saw employment decline by 32,000 jobs and electronics and appliance stores saw employment decline by 4,000 jobs in the month. Transportation and warehousing had a decline of 15,000 jobs in the month. I was somewhat surprised to see these two sectors decline considering it's the holiday season, but the excess inventory levels could be weighing on employment as retailers could be trying to focus on expenses including labor and transportation and warehousing. The item I believe weighed most on the markets was the increase of 5.1% in average hourly earnings. It surpassed the estimate of 4.6% and it could give the Fed more ammo to continue on its rate hiking path as it tries to bring down inflation. I do believe this should not be a major concern for the Fed because, like inflation overall, I think wage gains will begin to slow to a more normalized level next year as the job market decelerates.
Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE)
The PCE, which is known as the Personal Consumption Expenditures, came out at 6% for October over the last 12 months. As we had predicted months ago these inflation indexes would show signs of easing. This is why there has been some recovery in equities. The PCE is what the Federal Reserve looks at in regard to interest rates so there probably will not be any surprises going forward. We continue to believe that inflation will slow down and if you’ve been out of the market and in particular the right equities since summer you have missed out. There are still some opportunities to get back in for quality long-term investors but sitting on the sidelines for the next 6 to 12 months based on current data will be a mistake.
National Retail Federation (NRF)
You’ve probably heard that this is not going to be a great Christmas for retail. But as we say many times in our posts and other commentary, it’s important to understand what is being said and how it is being said. The estimate by the National Retail Federation (NRF) for holiday sales is expected to be between $942 billion to $960 billion, an increase of 6-8% over the $889 billion in 2021. This was a 13.5% increase over 2020. If we look back to 2019 when the economy was pretty strong, and everyone felt good, the NRF said holiday sales were $716 billion. Comparing the low end for 2022 of $942 billion, that’s a 31.6% increase from 2019. It does appear holiday shopping has gotten off to a good start considering the record of 196.7 million shoppers from Thanksgiving Day through Cyber Monday. This topped last year's level of 176 million shoppers and easily surpassed the NRF's estimate for 166.3 million shoppers. I don’t know about you, but I think those are pretty good numbers, all things being equal.
SEC
The SEC, also known as the Securities Exchange Commission, had a busy fiscal year, which ended September 30th. Their penalties were up 67% from the previous year, hitting an all-time record of $6.4 billion. I wonder where that money will go, or will it get lost in the tangled web of government administration? The money is supposed to go to a fund that either protects investors, a fund that refunds investors who lost money, or the third option, the US treasury general fund.
Carvana
If you’ve been patient waiting to buy a used car at a good price, that day may be here. Especially if you go to Carvana which became the place to go to get a used car during the pandemic. The company recently reported a net loss for the quarter of $508 million and that caused them to spend over $700 million of their cash during the quarter. The stock has dropped to under $7 a share after being as high as $360 per share last year. While this is not good news for the shareholders this could be good news for consumers. With financial issues like the company now has they are probably willing to make some very good deals to improve their cash flow. However, be aware that 6 to 12 months from now they could be bankrupt, and they could leave you out in the cold in regard to your car warranty.
Gross Domestic Product (GDP)
At our investment firm Wilsey Asset Management, we stand behind our belief that the recession will be extremely mild in 2023. There are people preparing for a terrible downturn in the markets and the economy. We have talked about reasons why we don’t see that happening and let me give you some more reasons. The current GDP, which is the Gross Domestic Product of our country, is about $20 trillion. We have talked about liquid money in the economy called M2, that is still at $21 trillion. Another factor that people are not thinking about is the $11 trillion in equity in US homes. If consumers were to spend just 10% of that equity and cash in M2 was reduced by 10% that would be over $3 trillion coming into the economy, or about a 15% gain in the GDP. Even if I’m wrong by 50% and only $1.5 trillion comes into the economy, that would still be a huge increase in economic output of 7.5%. The markets would get extremely excited if we had even a 4% growth in the economy which would be only $1.3 trillion coming from the $33 trillion from cash and equity. With all the liquidity how could we have a major recession? By the way, the average home in United States is now roughly 40 years old, which is the oldest since World War II. I think some of that money will go into home remodeling.
JOLTS
The Job Openings & Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS) showed job openings in October still remained high as they came in at 10.33 million. Compared to the prior month openings fell 353,000 and compared to last October openings were lower by a total of 760,000. Although this might sound troubling, there are still 1.7 job openings per available worker. Don't confuse a decelerating job market with a weak job market. With this report I still remain confident the downside risk to the economy is not as bad as many are worried about.
National Home Price Index
Pending home sales have now fallen for 5 months in a row. In the month of October, they were down 4.6% compared to September and they fell 37% compared to last October. With demand faltering I continue to believe 2023 will be a difficult year for housing prices. Although limited supply may cap losses, I do not see a catalyst that can drive prices higher. When looking at the S&P CoreLogic Case-Shiller National Home Price index home prices fell 1% in September compared to August. This was the third straight monthly decline and while prices remain positive on an annual basis this year when we lap these price gains in 2023, I believe you will see annual price declines.
General Motors
If you have a Tesla, you may be wondering how to get it serviced or may have experienced how inconvenient it is to get it serviced. General Motors has come to the rescue. With 90% of Americans living within 10 miles of a GM dealership they have begun to service Tesla cars. Since 2021 they have repaired 11,180 Tesla's. GM president Mark Reuss says they have been offering maintenance and repair services to Tesla owners since 2021. Tesla customers have been complaining about how bad the service can be, sometimes waiting months for parts or being charged excessively high repair bills. This is why competition is good, General Motors has experience in repairing EV‘s and Tesla is now investing millions of dollars to build more repair facilities near General Motor dealerships to improve their service.
US Debt
Japan is the third largest economy in the world and the largest purchaser of the US debt. They currently hold about $1.2 trillion of debt and there are some major signs that the Japanese are done buying our debt. With a strong dollar along with short term rates being higher than long-term rates it no longer makes sense for the Japanese to trade our debt. This could be a sign of higher rates going forward because if we can’t get investors to buy our debt at current interest rates the only way to entice them is to have rates rise more. The US economy has really been put into a pickle.
Inflation
We have seen inflation cool off a little bit and interest rates fall back a little as well, but this is all been based on the price of goods. What I have also been watching is the price of services. One benefit is housing costs are approximately 40% of the CPI and they are slowing down. Roughly 25% of the CPI comes from services such as healthcare, childcare, and insurance. We do have a tight labor market and that could push service prices higher, but some people took the layoffs at tech companies as a problem, I think it could turn out to be a benefit. This would mean the labor pool has people that can switch and go into the service sector. For now, I’m still comfortable saying the December inflation report released in January should see inflation between the 6-7% range. In 2023 I will continue to be watching the labor market and prices in the service sector.
Housing Market
We all know the housing market is slowing down and it’s not just those purchasing a home to live in but also real estate investors. From the 2nd to 3rd quarter, investors reduced home purchases by 30% from 94,000 in Q2 down to 66,000 in Q3. I think we could see that trend continue into the fourth quarter.