SMART INVESTING NEWSLETTER
Inflation Numbers, PPI, REITs, Bitcoin ETF, S&P 500, Oil Drilling, AI Startups, Return Policies, Value & Growth Investing, Undocumented Immigrant Healthcare and Social Security Spousal Benefits
Inflation Numbers
While the headline inflation numbers were above estimates, I wouldn’t say there were really any surprises in the Consumer Price Index (CPI) report. Headline CPI rose 3.4% vs the estimate of 3.2% and core CPI rose 3.9% vs the estimate of 3.8%. Although it was slightly higher than anticipated, progress is still being made on the inflation fight and core CPI registered its lowest reading since May 2021. As it has been the case for many months, the shelter index was the major contributor as the annual increase of 6.2% accounted for about two-thirds of the rise in inflation. Other areas that remained problematic included motor vehicle insurance (+20.3%), admission to sporting events (+14.9%), and motor vehicle repair (+10.3%). One area I found interesting was food, the entire index increased just 2.7% from last year but the divide between at home and away from home has widened substantially. The at home index showed an increase of just 1.3% compared to the away from home index which grew 5.2%. I believe this divide will remain due to the demand for dining out and the wage pressure restaurants and bars are facing. Overall, I don’t think this report moves the needle one way or another for the Fed and I believe rate cuts will start in the back half of the year.
PPI
More good news on the inflation front, as the Producer Price Index (PPI) showed an increase of just 1.0% compared to last year. Core PPI, which excludes food and energy, was up just 2.5% compared to last year. This points to more good news ahead on the inflation front as the PPI is normally a leading indicator.
REITs
With what I believe was the last rate hike of the cycle in the books, one area to evaluate is real estate. I’m not talking about single family homes or private investments, but rather looking at public Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs). These trade on the stock exchange, but instead of owning a business you will own the real estate that is bought within the trust. I believe there are many great values in the public real estate market at this time when analyzing the cash flows that an investor receives and historically REITs have outperformed the S&P 500 index by approximately 4.5 percentage points in the 12 months following the last interest-rate hike in a cycle. Looking at the last three hiking cycles, REITs have had an average total return of 19% in the 12 months following the last hike in a cycle. I believe the right real estate in the portfolio is a great area to look for value as we look down the road 2-3 years, not to mention many of these REITs have great dividend yields.
Bitcoin ETF
The hype for the bitcoin ETF is at all-time highs, as the SEC has now approved them for investments. We still don’t understand why people would want to buy an ETF that holds just one product like bitcoin. But for those who do, the fees are out and Fidelity has disclosed they will charge .39% annually for holding bitcoin. Their ETF competitors Invesco and crypto firm galaxy will charge 0.59% for holding bitcoin. I’m sure you’ve heard of the Grayscale bitcoin trust which charged an annual fee of 2% on the assets, they have now reduced that fee to 1.5% since it is now an ETF. I still believe this is hype, where the rumor will be far better than the news. I would not be surprised that for 2024 bitcoin is currently trading around its highs for the year.
S&P 500
We have posted many times during 2023 about the overconcentrated S&P 500 where nearly 1/3 of the return came from just seven companies. That did straighten out a little bit in the last quarter as the equally weighted S&P 500 index rose more than the market cap S&P 500 index. But even with that change, it was still noted 71% of stocks were still trailing the S&P 500 as of December 31st. I continue to believe and project that the craziness of seven stocks accounting for such a large amount of the return will be changing in 2024. I think you will see other equities do better than the magnificent seven, but they won’t move the market as much because of their smaller market cap and therefore smaller weight in the index.
Oil Drilling
I remember when President Joe Biden first got in office, there were concerns because he was going to shutdown much of the oil drilling. The concern back then was oil was going to surpass $150 per barrel and gas prices would be $7 per gallon at the pump. Fast forward to January 2024 and reviewing the results from last year, the country averaged a record 12.9 million barrels of daily crude oil production in 2023. This was an increase of 1 million barrels per day from 2022. The US also relaxed US enforcement of sanctions on Iran and they increased their exports which helped drive down oil prices. Even with the sanctions on Russia, oil still flowed fairly freely which also kept prices low. By the way, the lower prices actually hurt Russia. For years I have said yes, the President of the United States has a lot of power, but many times market forces will override what the president tries to do. No matter who gets in office in November, the market forces will still continue to run the country and whoever is President won’t be able to do as much as people are afraid of. Vote for whoever you think is the best candidate, but don’t be too upset if the person you wanted for President doesn’t win. We will once again make it through the next four years until 2028, this is still the greatest country in the world.
AI Startups
Artificial intelligence, known as AI, better live up to that hype and pretty quickly for companies like Microsoft, Google, and Amazon. Just in 2023 they raised $27 billion in AI startups. If that number sounds large, it is and not just because it’s a large number but because it’s 2/3 of the total amount raised for AI startups.
Return Policies
Many more stores and outlets over the years have followed companies like Costco with a no questions asked return policy. I do believe this has boosted sales, but it has also increased returns. For the 2022 holiday season, from Thanksgiving to January 31st returns to stores were $186 billion. Holiday sales in 2023 as reported earlier were up 3.1% from 2022, but apparently it is projected the cost of product returns for the period from Thanksgiving to the end of January is looking like it may have declined to $173 billion. My interpretation, that is a positive for the retailers because sales are up and returns were down which means more profits in the retailers’ pockets.
Value and Growth Investing
What type of investor are you? There are two main strategies when investing in the stock market, growth stocks and value stocks. At our firm we stick to value investing because we know over history it has done very well. Looking over the last 15 years though, growth has beaten value. If we look at the Russell 3000 Growth Index it is up close to 700%, while the Russell 3000 Value Index is up just around 200%. As an investor, the hard part is you have to understand the strategies come into and fall out of favor and realistically you can’t time it. If we look at another period of time, from 1970 to early 2007, value stocks on average outperformed growth by about 7 percentage points per year. The hardest part is as an investor you can’t pick the strategy based on what happened over the past few years and instead need to understand what you believe are good investments going forward. Hindsight of course will always be 20/20. One other reason I favor value investing is because of the downside risk. Over history, there are risks value may not produce as a high of a return as growth over certain periods but the downside is nothing like what we have seen with growth. A great example is the tech bust where the Nasdaq fell close to 80% in just a two-year period from 2000 to 2002. It also then took about 15 years to get back to its tech boom peak. While value has not performed as well over the last 15 years, I will stick to the value strategy as catastrophes like the tech bust can completely derail an investor and unfortunately the lessons that should have been learned are easily forgotten as time passes and I am confident history will repeat itself again.
Undocumented Immigrant Healthcare
I was very disappointed to learn that starting in July, the Governor of California is going to spend $3.1 billion for healthcare for 700,000 undocumented immigrants. There are many people in California who pay taxes and are having a hard time paying their health insurance because they want to do the right thing. For the state of California to give away $3.1 billion when we now have a rising deficit is just wrong in so many ways. When voting, please look at what that politician stands for and not on some superficial thoughts.
Financial Planning: Social Security Spousal Benefits
Social Security spousal benefits come into play when one spouse has little to no earnings history. In this case their own social security benefits would be low, so they can claim a spousal benefit from the spouse that did work. There’s a common misconception that it’s ½ of the higher earning spouse’s amount, but the actual calculation is ½ of the working spouse’s full retirement age amount and the non-working spouse would need to apply at their own full retirement age. The working spouse may apply at any point between age 62 and 70 and the spousal benefit is still ½ of their age 67 amount. The non-working spouse may collect as early as age 62, but they will receive a reduced benefit for every month they collect before age 67. Upon reaching age 67, they do not receive a larger benefit by waiting any longer. The only other caveat is the working spouse must be collecting social security for the non-working spouse to collect a spousal benefit. In situations where the higher earning spouse is not collecting social security because they are still working or they are waiting until age 70, this prevents the non-working spouse from collecting. If the non-working spouse has reached age 67, benefits are being permanently lost. This is compounded by the fact that the spousal benefits will only last until the death of either spouse because only the higher social security benefit is retained by a surviving spouse. This is one of several instances where it is better to collect Social Security sooner rather than later.