SMART INVESTING NEWSLETTER
Inflation, Consumer Spending, Debt Ceiling, Costco Buybacks Program, 3D Printing, Diesel Inflation, Chip Production, Tesla Stock, Streaming Sports, Foreign Arm Sales, Holiday Spending...
Inflation
Big news on the inflation fronts today as the Producer Price Index (PPI) in December showed a monthly decline of 0.5% vs the estimate for a decline of 0.1%. Year over year the index showed an increase of 6.2% which is the lowest annual increase since March 2021 and is far from the high in March 2022 of 11.7%. This is a major positive as for over a year now I've been saying the CPI won't come down until the PPI comes down, as producers have needed to pass the higher costs onto consumers. A problem in the report is energy was a major benefit as the energy index fell 7.9% in the month and gasoline in particular was down 13.4%. Given the current landscape I do expect energy prices to increase from current levels, but not enough to make a dramatic difference to the inflation reports. Overall, this report gives me confidence in my estimate that we will see inflation in a range of 4-6% for 2023.
Consumer Spending
Retail sales for December fell 1.1% compared to the prior month, this missed the estimate of 0.8%. Looking at the results compared to last December, retail sales climbed 6.0%. This did not keep pace with the CPI increase in the month of 6.5%, which likely means most if not all of the growth in retail sales was a function of higher prices. Areas that saw good growth compared to the prior year included non-store retailers as they were up 13.7%, food services and drinking places were up 12.1%, and grocery stores were up 7.3%. With lower gas prices in the month, gas stations saw a month over month decline of 4.6% but compared to last December sales were still 5.2% higher. Areas that struggled in the month continued to be electronics & appliances as sales fell 5.6%, department stores saw a decline of 0.6%, and furniture & home furnishing stores had a small gain of just 0.3%. I would say this report wasn't good, but again it wasn't overly concerning. It appears consumers are still spending but continue to prefer experiences rather than the products they loaded up on during Covid.
Debt Ceiling
You may have seen the news about the concerns regarding the debt ceiling of $31.4T being reached. Frankly, I'm not too concerned about major problems stemming from this as it has been a recurring issue. In fact, from 1997-2022 the debt ceiling has been increased 22 times, which is essentially once per year. I do believe a deal will be reached to avoid jeopardizing the creditworthiness of the government. My concern is that we need to fix spending as we should not have to keep increasing this debt ceiling every year.
Costco Buyback Program
I saw Costco announced a stock buyback program but looking at it closely it's unimpressive to say the least. The program authorizes $4 B worth of buybacks but that is through January 2027. The previous authorization was set to expire in April of this year and was adopted in 2019 with the same $4 B limit. Interestingly, the company only repurchased $1.4 B worth of shares under the program. Looking at the market cap for Costco of about $210 B, if the $4b was fully implemented that would only represent 1.9% of the overall shares. Also, considering the shares trade at about 30x 2024 earnings I believe repurchasing shares at this level would be a waste of capital.
3D Printing
10 years ago, when 3-D printing was all the rage DDD stock hit $92/share and I was saying this is too much hype and thought investors should stay away. Well now in 2023 I think it is time to look at perhaps investing in 3-D companies. First to understand how 3-D printing works it begins by adding tiny layers of material one at a time to form an item and fusing them with binding agents, lasers, or other methods. The parts are grown instead of forged, casted, or molded by machines. General Motors made 60,000 waterproof seals using 3-D printers and their new hot EV Cadillac Celestiq will include over 300 3-D printed parts. In 2022 the entire global 3-D printing market was around $13.3 billion, a nice increase from $5.7 billion six years ago. I think now may be the time to find value in a 3-D printing company.
Diesel Inflation
Good news for people on the East Coast. Not only is inflation coming down but supplies of diesel and heating oil have risen dramatically. With 34 million barrels of diesel and heating oil in reserve, that should end all fears of shortages this winter which means no spiking prices and people on the East Coast can stay warm.
Chip Production
It has been said that chips will be the next important “commodity” over the next 10-50 years. The same as oil has been over the last 50 years. This is why the United States is pushing so hard for chip manufacturing. Since 2020 semiconductor companies have proposed more than 40 projects valued at over $200 billion that would create over 40,000 jobs. This is great but there are a couple of problems. First engineering students are going more for chip design or software as opposed to manufacturing. We need more students to go into the manufacturing side of chips. Another problem is that it is so small in size, but so big is the lasers that imprint tiny circuit blueprints on silicon wafers using what is known as purified neon gas, which is made from raw neon. This is usually harvested from large air separating units attached to steel plants. If you remember your history, the steel industry has moved out of the US over the last 50 years, and you’ll never guess where neon gas is now being produced. If you guessed China, you’re correct. More was coming from Ukraine and Russia but with the current war, China is now the main source. Over the last 10 years the average car now uses 1200 chips which is double the 600 chips cars used just 10 years ago. Think about it, chips can be found in everything like appliances, phones and even now power tools that have Bluetooth chips to track their locations. If we don’t produce more chips over the coming years we could lose our place as a world power.
Tesla Stock
As I expected for years, nothing hot goes up forever. Tesla stock has dropped 70% as the car company is losing consumer interest. The annual growth of vehicles delivered to customers has slowed to 40%, more than a 50% cut from the 87% growth in 2021. In the final weeks of 2022 Tesla offered $7500 in discounts to try and boost demand. Last week Tesla cut prices for US consumers by as much as 20%. The car company has now gone three years without introducing a new model. I believe the car is becoming boring and other car makers are offering some very good alternatives. This has caused Tesla's share of the EV market to drop to 65% from about 72% the year before. Another concern for the car company and the stock is a survey conducted by JD power of EV buyers shows that 44% would buy a Chevrolet, 39% a Tesla and 37% will consider buying a Ford. After doing well for so many years I think the car company and its stock are coming back down to reality. I’m still very cautious on the stock because every day I hear it is more like a car company and if it were to trade like a car company the PE multiple would be around 6. Using the trailing 12-month earnings of $3.09, that would give a stock price of $19.16. I do not believe we will see Tesla trade at those levels, but the problem is what is the bottom for the stock? I don’t think anyone knows so I would rather watch from the sidelines.
Streaming Sports
The value of TV and streaming sports rights has gone through the roof and in my opinion it's now crazy and not profitable for those paying. It is estimated that the value of US TV sports rights is nearly $27 billion, approximately 75% higher than just seven years ago. This will be passed along to consumers as companies who advertise need to increase the price of their products to cover the higher cost of advertising and sports venues. There appears to be interest in other sports where the rates are much less expensive, like pickle ball. Don’t laugh, pickle ball, which combines tennis and badminton together received almost 700,000 TV viewers from a pro event last year.
Foreign Arm Sales
General Dynamics and Lockheed Martin could benefit from the Biden administration's attempt to get approval for a $20 billion sale of F-16 fighter jets to Turkey and also F-35 fighters to Greece. The sale must be approved by Congress, but there has never been a time that Congress has successfully blocked a foreign arm sale requested by the White House. There seems to be some concern with Turkey having ties to Kurdish separatist groups and also not being tough enough on Russian sanctions. I’ve always had some concerns about Turkey and was surprised to learn that they maintain the second largest army in NATO. I hope we’re not selling fighter jets to a future enemy.
Holiday Spending
Holiday sales may not have been as strong as initially anticipated, but I would still say they were good overall. The National Retail Federation (NRF) forecasted holiday sales in November and December would grow between 6 - 8% to a level of $942.6B - $960.4B. The forecast excludes spending at automobile dealers, gasoline stations and restaurants. The actual result was 5.3% year over year growth to $936.3B. While the report does not remove the impact of inflation, I believe the numbers still show that consumers were willing and able to spend this past holiday season. It remains in line with my expectation that the economy will have a small pullback, but I just don't see anything catastrophic.
Interest Rates
The rising interest rates not only affect consumers, but the government which is currently paying higher interest on the around $31 trillion in debt they have. With higher interest rates, the government has spent 37% more so far, this fiscal year compared to the same period last year. The increased cost of that interest, $57 billion.
Cancer Death Rates
The cancer death rate in the US has dropped about 33% due to positive things such as the fight against smoking, which has led to a reduction in smokers. Also helping has been preventative measures such as the HPV for younger women who are now in their 20s. Cervical cancer in women drop 65% from 2012 to 2019. One area that has been increasing unfortunately is prostate cancer in men which has increased about 4.5% each year since 2011.
Home Sales
Existing home sales fell for the 11th month in a row in December. Compared to last December, sales were down 34%. For all of 2022 sales were 17.8% lower than 2021. Price gains have moderated substantially and compared to last December the median price of $366,900 was up just 2.3%. As prices have declined in recent months, I continue to believe we will begin to see annual declines in the prices as we progress through 2023. Supply does remain a problem at just 2.9 months, but it has improved from the prior year when it was 1.7 months. I continue to believe 2023 will be a difficult year for housing prices.