SMART INVESTING NEWSLETTER
CPI, PPI, Retail Sales, Real Estate, Gold, Movie Theater, New Homes, Costco, Oil Prices, Bitcoin, Electric Vehicles, Tesla, Oil Futures and Economy Prediction
CPI
Headline CPI came in at 5% compared to last year, which was the lowest level since the May 2021 report and well off the June 2022 high of 9%. Some reasons for the slower gain include gasoline which was down 17.4%, used cars and trucks down 11.2%, televisions down 14%, and uncooked beef roasts down 4.4%. Areas that remain elevated include transportation services up 13.9% (Airfare was up 17.7%), electricity up 10.2%, and food was up 8.5%. The big problem in the report continues to be the shelter index which accounts for about 1/3 of CPI and rose 8.2%. Some people may point to a concern over core CPI, which takes out the volatile food and energy components, as it rose 5.6% compared to last year and was higher than February's reading of 5.5%. But looking closer at the numbers, the shelter index accounted for about 60% of the increase in core CPI. Excluding shelter, the CPI rose just 3.4% from a year ago. I continue to believe the shelter index will level off as we progress through the year and have a much smaller impact on CPI. Overall, I would say this inflation report was a major positive and should provide evidence to the Fed that a pause in rate hikes could make sense.
PPI
Huge news on the inflation fronts as the Producer Price Index (PPI) showed a month over month decline of 0.5% in the month of March. This was well below estimates for the index to be flat in the month. Looking at the 12-month change, the index showed an increase of just 2.7%. This was the smallest increase since January 2021 and is well off the high from last March of 11.7%. The Fed has pointed to concerns over services pricing, but this report also indicated that prices for services fell 0.3% in the month which was the largest decline since April 2020. With a report like this I really believe the Fed should consider not raising rates at the next meeting.
Retail Sales
The headline retail sales numbers may concern some, but digging through the numbers they indicate exactly what we've been anticipating, a slowing economy not a troubled economy. The headlines read that retail sales fell 1% in the month, more than the estimate of a 0.5% decline but looking at the numbers compared to last March sales increased 2.9%. It's important to point out that this is not adjusted for inflation, which was 5% in the month of March. The biggest negative weight on the numbers was the decline of 14.2% at gas stations largely due to the decline in gas prices. If we exclude gas stations from retail sales, they would have been up 4.8% compared to March 2022. Other negatives included electronics and appliance stores which were down 10.3%, building material & garden equipment & supplies dealers were down 3.5%, furniture and home furnishings stores were down 2.4%, and clothing and clothing accessory stores were down 1.8%. The major gainers in the report were food services and drinking places which were up 13%, non-store retailers were up 12.3%, health and personal care stores were up 7.1%, and food and beverage stores were up 5.0%.
Real Estate
Real estate transactions remain on the low side as housing prices are beginning to weaken. With the higher prices of homes and the higher interest rates many first-time buyers have been locked out of the housing market. The movement of the real estate market generally happens where people will trade up to perhaps a larger or more expensive home opening the lower priced homes for first time buyers. But with many of these homes the homeowners locked in mortgage rates in the 3% range, and they don’t see the benefit of buying a more expensive home with mortgage rates double what they’re paying now. I believe it will take years for the real estate market to adjust to a more normal market.
Gold
Gold passed $2000 per ounce recently, coming close to the record high set in 2020 of $2,069.40. There are three things that can move gold. First gold generally rises when the dollar falls in value. As bond yields climb competition for gold can increase because gold produces no income. Third, people invest in gold due to risk aversion for a comfort feeling. Based on these three factors I would not be convinced that gold has much left on the upside. I believe there are some valuable equities that are a far better place to invest one’s money over the next 6 to 12 months, many also include attractive dividend yields.
Movie Theater
We thought about going to the movies on Saturday night but once again we did not make it. That seems to happen a lot these days but apparently, we are not the only ones. Domestic movie box office sales in 2022 hit $7.5 billion. This is over three times what it was back in 2020 during the pandemic when sales came in at $2.3 billion. At our investment firm Wilsey Asset Management we like to compare today’s numbers to numbers back in 2019 before the pandemic. Box office sales in 2019 were $11.4 billion.
New Homes
The number of listings for new homes continues to slide and according to Realtor.com, in the month of March there was a 20% decline compared to last year. Compared to pre-pandemic levels, new listings in the month were 30% lower. The interesting part here is the active inventory is 60% higher than at the start of last spring as homes are taking longer to sell. Homes on the market have averaged 54 days, up from an average of 36 days at the start of last spring. While inventory remains problematic, I just don't see the demand surge coming to push prices higher.
Costco
Last week Costco reported disappointing sales to investors. For the month of March sales only increased by 2.6%, which is roughly half of the 5% growth experienced in February and well off the 12.2% in the same month one year ago when the stock was about $120 higher than it is now. I do believe it is time to stay away from Costco, I’m not talking about shopping there I’m talking about the stock because I don’t believe their sales will look much better for months to come. If one were to include the gas sales in the total for same store sales, that’s a worse picture as there was a 1.1% decline. People may think I hate Costco, but that is not true. I love going to Costco, but I hate a stock that trades at 35 times earnings when the historical average is between 14- and 17-times earnings. Their products are well priced, their stock is not.
Oil Prices
Last week we talked about why oil prices could be going up in the future as OPEC had a surprise production cut. After the dust has settled a little bit, the spike upwards may not be as bad as it appeared after the surprise cut. The reason for my optimism is looking at oil futures going out to December 2023, they are trading around $81.50/barrel which is below the current price around $85/barrel. We will continue to watch the situation but at this time feel we may not have much more of a spike in oil and gas prices even with the summer driving season coming up. Those consumers living in California may have a different outcome based on the foolish actions of Governor Newsom that we discussed last week.
Bitcoin
Once again, Bitcoin has defied all logic and has surpassed the $30,000 level. There is no reason that has been stated from reliable sources why this is happening. We have explained before that the SEC is closing in many corners of the cryptocurrency world. In my opinion, this could be one of the reasons why Bitcoin continues to rise in defiance of regulation. I, nor does anyone else have any idea when bitcoin will change direction and head south or at what point it will begin to fall again. I do believe the Bitcoin market is being manipulated and unfortunately the little guy will be left holding the bag and there will be no place for the little guy to turn to for reimbursement. Please remember investing in Bitcoin, or any other cryptocurrency is the purest form of speculation.
Electric Vehicles
Good news came out last week for electric vehicles because of a 30% decline in lithium prices in 2023. Lithium is a big expense for electric vehicles because of the batteries and this could even perhaps ease the price of electric vehicles going forward. I do have to point out on the other side of the coin that lithium prices climbed 1200% over the past two years.
Tesla
I recently noticed that once again Tesla has cut prices on their cars. This is the fifth price cut over the last few months. Initially it would appear to be a good thing. What worries me is consumers may be thinking they’ll be another price cut and will wait for the next one before buying a Tesla. This could hurt their sales going forward and the stock price as well. I did notice that their market share has come down. They are still the monster in EV sales with 62.8% market share, but it used to be above 70%. As I thought, with more players coming into the market, Tesla has seen reductions in their market share. General Motors is coming on strong from way behind and is now number two in EV market share with 7.9%.
Oil Futures
Oil futures have been moving up and down recently on different news being released. It was quite the scare when the Saudis announced oil production cuts and the price of oil shot up because of concern of lower supply going forward. Then more surprising news came out that countries such as Nigeria, Kazakhstan, Iran and Norway have been increasing their daily oil production since September 2022. These four countries combined have increased their production by 981,000 barrels per day which is greater than the Saudi cut of 560,000 barrels per day and the United Arab Emirates cut of 250,000. I was happy to see that even the United States has increased our daily production by 67,000 barrels per day. This is good news for the price of oil and gas at the pump. But we have to remember that some of these places that oil is coming from around the world have unstable political governments. But for now, let’s enjoy the good news of the increase in production and supply.
Economy Prediction
I continue to believe we will not have a real recession, only a slowdown in growth. We have pointed out before about how the strong job market will keep the economy going. In addition to that, spending on non-residential construction continues to be very strong. It has climbed 17% higher than last February totaling $982 billion. The backlog of non-residential projects is now 9.2 months surpassing levels going back to 2019. The reason for the boost in non-residential construction is many new plants for electric vehicles, warehouses for e-commerce, and manufacturers moving more operations back to the US after supply chain problems during the pandemic. Last year saw a record amount of money spent on manufacturing, I believe that trend will continue. When you hear somebody tell you that the economy is going to hit a major recession, ask them about the strong job market and the strength of non-residential construction spending. I bet they don’t have any idea what the numbers are.