SMART INVESTING NEWSLETTER
Chinese Economy, Cava, Recession, Inflation, Disney Stock, Bitcoin, Student Loans, Political System, Dow Jones and Auto Market
Chinese Economy
It looks like the Chinese economy may be slowing down. In June, exports fell 12.4% and between 2012 and 2022 their debt has increased by $10 trillion. Local governments who benefited from a strong real estate market are now knocking on Beijing’s door for assistance. A major problem appears to be that they have turned back to a centrally controlled communist party leadership. This has undermined the private sector and created a struggling economy. China’s economy is still very large, and it has a strong military and technical capacities so we can count them out. However, in the years to come a weak economy in China could be a positive for the US as China would perhaps seek better relations with us to help their economy continue to grow.
Cava
The new restaurant Cava is being touted as perhaps the next Chipotle. Is it hype or a possibility? The pros are making similarities, such as Cava getting the same $22 per share as Chipotle did back in 2006. Both restaurants also doubled on their IPO. Wilsey Asset Management being a value investment firm, would not be investing in either of these restaurants because of the excessively high valuations they trade at. Some investors of Cava are thinking maybe it will make them a millionaire? Some interesting data for the Cava restaurant investors. The market value is $5.9 billion over three times Chipotle’s $1.4 billion after their IPO. Chipotle was profitable and had 450 restaurants almost double Cava’s 263, of which 151 of them came from a $300 million purchase of Zoe’s kitchen. Cava has not seen a profit yet. Chipotle had 3187 restaurants at the end of 2022 and the restaurants grew with a compounded annual growth rate of 11.8%. Cava is projecting that they will have 1000 locations by 2032, which is a very aggressive annual growth rate of 16%. There are many risks that the expansion does not go according to plan which would be extremely troubling for the stock.
Recession
Recession…. What recession? Some have feared that we’ve been in the middle of a recession, but Q2 GDP growth of 2.4% shows the economy continues to move along. While the number easily topped the estimate of 2%, the report shows consumer spending is continuing to decelerate. Personal consumption expenditures increased 1.6% in the quarter and accounted for over 45% of the increase in GDP, but they did decelerate substantially compared to Q1 when personal consumption expenditures were up 4.2%. It’s important to remember that consumer spending accounts for close to 70% of GDP. Services continue to carry consumer spending as it was up 2.1% in Q2 vs an increase of just 0.7% for goods. Private investment was also a nice boost in the quarter as it was up 5.7% vs the decline of 11.9% in Q1. Residential investment saw a decline of 4.2%, but that was more than offset by growth of 9.7% in structures and growth of 10.8% in equipment investment. Change in business inventories was a big hit to Q1 GDP as it subtracted 2.14% from the headline number, but in Q2 there was positive benefit to GDP of 0.14%. Government spending was also positive in the quarter as it grew 2.6% and trade was the only negative of the major components as it subtracted 0.12% from the headline number. This came as the fall in exports of 10.8% outpaced the fall in imports of 7.8%. This report provides further evidence that while we may be in the middle of a slowdown, we may be able to avoid a recession.
Inflation
Another measure for inflation, the personal consumption expenditures price index (PCE), showed inflation continues to decelerate. At the headline level, PCE rose 0.2% compared to the prior month and it was up just 3.0% compared to last year. This was a decline from last month’s reading of 3.8% and it was the lowest reading since March 2021. Core PCE, which excludes food and energy, was up just 0.2% compared to the prior month and it was up 4.1% compared to last year. This was down from last month’s reading of 4.6% and it was the lowest reading since September 2021. While inflation is still not at the Fed’s 2% target, I believe it will continue to work its way there over the next year to two. This report provides further evidence that the economy is continuing to grow, albeit at a slower pace, and inflation is continuing on its path of deceleration which I believe bodes well for the economy and the right stocks.
Disney Stock
At our investment firm, Wilsey Asset Management, we always discuss how it takes us 10 to 20 hours of research before we decide if we want to invest in a certain equity for our portfolio. We look at many different factors, and we found one of interest for those who are considering investing in Disney. July 4th is a busy day for theme parks and I noticed that based on wait times either less people are attending the theme park or somehow Disney is getting more people on the rides at a faster rate. If you were at Disney July 4, 2023, you only had to wait in line 27 minutes. This compares to last year when you had to wait 31 minutes and if you went to the park before Covid back in 2019 you spent 47 minutes in line. Is that a positive or negative? Just one piece of data that we would be looking at if we had an interest in investing in Disney.
Bitcoin
As Bitcoin still hovers around $30,000, I continue to see a lot of negatives in the cryptocurrency world. Binance, the largest cryptocurrency exchange by trading volume, earlier this year had 8000 employees but has now laid off 1000 employees and their CEO says there’s more to follow within the next six months. They also are cutting benefits for current employees, that was effective June 19th. Just a few weeks ago I remember reading four of their top executives left the company. Advocates of cryptocurrency and Bitcoin talk about the positives, such as the Hong Kong government officials and regulators being on the positive side of cryptocurrencies. If one looks a little deeper, they will find that banks in Hong Kong are very nervous about cryptocurrencies and they are resisting opening accounts that hold money of crypto exchange clients. In my opinion, I believe Hong Kong and the rest of the world is watching the lawsuits in the United States against cryptocurrency firms. This includes statements from the Federal Reserve, with one saying “issuing or holding cryptocurrencies is highly likely to be inconsistent with safe and sound banking practices.” Some banks in Hong Kong have even pointed out a concern of cryptocurrencies is that they will be used to launder money. I know we have over 35,000 followers on social media and there are a few who are advocates for cryptocurrencies, but at Wilsey Asset Management we still continue to believe this will end badly for cryptocurrency investors.
Student Loans
The return of student loan payments for tens of millions of students who borrowed money is coming to a close after a three year reprieve. According to Wells Fargo, the average monthly payment is between $210-$314 per student which would amount to a pay cut of around 4-5% based on the U.S. median household income before taxes. Approximately 37 million borrowers saved somewhere around $195 billion during the pause, but unfortunately many of them did not save that money or use it to pay down other debts. It is estimated about 20% of those approximately 37 million borrowers are going to struggle to make the monthly payments. In my day the answer was simple, work a little bit more to collect overtime or as I did, work in college to make extra money. I personally took on a job in a drug store. There are plenty of companies out there looking for workers in retail stores and restaurants that would hire someone part time.
Political System
We may complain about having a Republican or a Democrat president, but overall our political system seems to work pretty well. I remember years ago and even sometimes today people talk about how great Europe is. Well, looking over the last 15 years the Eurozone economy only grew by about 6%. This is far below the US growth of 82% according to the International Monetary Fund. The data also pointed out that the average EU country is poorer per person than every US state except Idaho and Mississippi. So while we may complain about the problems we have here in our country, people in the euro zone are seeing rising inflation which is causing a decline in real wages. Adjusted for inflation and purchasing power, wages have declined by about 3% since 2019 in Germany, by 3.5% in Italy and Spain and by 6% in Greece. Real wages in the U.S. have increased by about 6% over the same period. This has hurt consumer spending as private consumption in the 20 nation Eurozone over the last four years has declined by 1% compared with a 9% increase in the United States. Yes we have problems here, but if we continue to work hard, we will continue to remain a great country with a very nice lifestyle that should not be taken for granted.
Dow Jones
After 13 days of advances, the Dow Jones’ win streak officially came to a close. The 13 day period marked the best winning streak since 1987 and if it would have been able to close higher for a 14th day, it would have matched the longest streak ever which was achieved in June 1897. This occurred approximately one year after the Dow was created in May 1896. Even after the lengthy win streak, the Dow is up just 6.68%.
Auto Market
I was surprised to see the stocks of both GM and Ford head lower after their earnings reports considering they both beat on earnings and raised guidance. Investors may be worried about a slowdown in demand, but I believe there could still be runway in the auto market. This is in part due to the fact that the average age of passenger cars and trucks in operation increased to 12.2 years in 2022, up from about 10.5 years in 2010. With aging vehicles these automakers transitions to a larger EV base may be easier as consumers look to replace their vehicles. Considering the low valuations for both these stocks, I think they are definitely worth a look.